1.888.994.6376

Call Windsor today!

(888)-994-6376

Life Settlement Companies /

Coventry First

Contact

Coventry First
coventry.com
877-836-8300
info@coventry.com

Resources

Read Reviews
Settlement Calculator

Market Role

Direct Buyer
Buys policies directly

Qualification

Generally works with policyowners age 65 and older, or younger insureds with a meaningful change in health. Universal life, whole life, and convertible term policies are the usual targets. The Simplified Settlements program handles policies between $100,000 and $500,000 and can close within about 30 days once all information is submitted.

Short Summary

Coventry First is the licensed provider at the center of the Coventry group of companies and the largest buyer of life insurance policies in the United States. Coventry has held the top spot in The Deal league tables every year since the rankings were first published in 2013. In 2022, Coventry and its affiliate Life Equity bought more than 1,500 policies, over three times as many as the next closest buyer, and more than 52 percent of all life settlement transactions that year.
Coventry First LLC is the licensed provider within the Coventry group of companies. Coventry Direct is the consumer-facing intake brand and Life Equity is an affiliated provider. Both also appear in this directory.
Coventry First homepage shown on a desktop monitor

Company Reviews

Coventry First holds a 5.0 rating from 4 reviews on its own Google Business Profile. The volume is small for the largest buyer in the country, which reflects the fact that most sellers arrive through the Coventry Direct brand rather than the provider entity.

The reviews name individuals. Andrew Stewart, Peter Hershon and Samuel Brenman are each credited by a seller for handling a transaction. One describes a term policy sale completed inside three weeks. Another describes a representative working patiently with an elderly parent through the paperwork.

The larger public record sits under Coventry Direct and it is more mixed. Positive reviews mention responsive case managers and a process that moves quickly once underwriting is complete. Critical reviews cluster around offer amounts sellers felt were low, and long waits that ended in a decline after months of paying premiums. That split is normal for any direct buyer. Nobody writes a happy review about an offer they turned down.

last verified:
07/27/2026

A Closer Look For Policyowners

Coventry built this market. That is not marketing language, it is history. The company ran the first modern life settlement transactions and has led the industry in volume for over a decade. It is well capitalized, it closes what it agrees to close, and it has the underwriting depth to price complicated cases that smaller buyers pass on. Windsor has taken cases to Coventry for years and expects a real answer.

Coventry is also the only buyer most sellers can name, because it spends the most on advertising. Familiarity is not the same as a better price. If a policy is going to one buyer and speed is worth more than dollars, Coventry is a credible choice. If the goal is the highest number, one offer from the largest buyer is still one offer.

Anyone researching Coventry will find the lawsuits, so here they are without spin. In October 2006, New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer sued Coventry First, alleging the company made secret payments to life settlement brokers that were disguised as co-brokering fees. The state claimed these concealed commissions led brokers to steer clients toward Coventry offers instead of higher bids from rival providers. Coventry was not assessed any fines. It paid $12 million to settle the case and agreed to reform some of its operations. A Florida Office of Insurance Regulation investigation also ended in a settlement.

There is also an active dispute. Abacus sued Coventry and Executive Chairman Alan Buerger in July 2025, alleging a years-long campaign to spread false statements about Abacus to regulators, auditors, analysts, and investors. On June 26, 2026, a federal court in Florida ruled that Abacus had plausibly alleged defamation and anticompetitive conduct, and let the case move forward. Coventry has called the suit an attempt to silence constitutionally protected debate about life expectancy estimates and industry practices. Nothing has been decided. Both companies are on this list, and both are still active buyers.

Two things are true at once. The 2006 case is twenty years old and was settled without a finding of liability. And it is the clearest illustration on record of why a broker loyalty has to sit with the seller and nowhere else.

Understanding The Market

Here is the plain math. A buyer that already wins more than half the policies sold in a given year does not need to stretch on any single case. It can bid at its target return, lose some deals, and still lead the market on volume. Smaller buyers that need to build a portfolio often have to bid harder to win the same policy.

That is not a criticism of Coventry. It is what market position does to pricing behavior, and any buyer in that seat would behave the same way. It is also the entire reason competitive bidding exists.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Coventry First legitimate?

Yes. Coventry First is a licensed life settlement provider and the largest buyer of life insurance policies in the country. It has been active for more than twenty years.

Is Coventry First the same as Coventry Direct?

Not exactly. They are part of the same group. Coventry Direct is the consumer-facing brand that advertises and gathers policy information. Coventry First is the licensed provider that buys the policy. Life Equity is a third company in the group.

Is Coventry a broker or a direct buyer?

A direct buyer. Coventry buys policies for its own account and for its investor partners. It does not represent the seller and does not owe the seller a fiduciary duty.

Was Coventry First sued for bid-rigging?

Yes. The New York Attorney General filed suit in 2006 alleging concealed payments to brokers. Coventry paid $12 million to settle, was not fined, and agreed to change some practices.

How much does Coventry pay for a life insurance policy?

It depends on the insured age, health, policy type, face amount, and premium load. Coventry prices to its own return targets rather than against competing bids.

How long does the Coventry process take?

The Simplified Settlements program targets about 30 days for policies between $100,000 and $500,000. Larger or more complex cases take longer, often several months, because of medical underwriting.

Does Coventry buy policies from terminally ill policyholders?

Coventry handles both life settlements and viatical cases. Anyone with a terminal or chronic diagnosis should also check whether their policy has an accelerated death benefit before selling anything.

Should I go to Coventry directly or use a broker?

Going direct is simpler and can be faster. A broker takes the same policy to Coventry and to every other buyer at the same time, which is how competing offers get created. Coventry has raised its offers when other bidders were in the room.

Can I get more than one offer from Coventry?

Coventry will give you its offer. Getting a second, third, and fourth offer means going to other buyers, which is what a broker does.

Is selling to the largest buyer the safest choice?

Size means the company can close and can pay. It does not mean the offer is the highest. Those are two different questions and both are worth asking.

Speak To A Fiduciary At Windsor

Monday-Friday
9am-5pm CT
1-888-994-6376

Life Settlement Resources